I love a good theme party, so when my husband suggested that we have a Hawaiian Luau party for his 31st birthday I was incredibly excited. Immediately, I began to brainstorm what kind of foods we would serve as the food is always my favorite part of any party. Carlos jokingly suggested that we roast a pig on a spit, much to my horror, but he ultimately decided on pulled pork sandwiches (with pork purchased at the store) and various sides. For an appetizer, we made bacon wrapped jalapeños stuffed with cream cheese, both a regular version and a vegetarian version. Accompanying the pulled pork sandwiches was a spaghetti salad as well as chips and salsa. For the vegetarians in the group, we used the Gardein sweet and sour porkless bites. I had never had this kind of sandwich before and I was amazed at how well the pork bites, coleslaw, and King’s Hawaiian rolls complemented each other. I loved it so much that we made it again for dinner last night!
For dessert, I wanted to do a cake that was on theme, however, Carlos also wanted a special birthday cake. I decided to make two cakes as we anticipated having around 20 people, and we still ended up having mountains of cake left over! The on theme cake that I made was a Hawaiian Wedding Cake. This recipe came from one of the ladies who goes to my parent’s church. It is simple to make and turned out well, however I will adjust a few aspects of the recipe next time that I make it.
I followed the recipe, however I did find one direction confusing. Where it says “Blend cream cheese with pudding and gradually add milk,” I didn’t know whether it meant to blend the cream cheese with fully prepared pudding or to mix it with the pudding powder. My mother believed that it meant to mix it with the pudding powder, so that is what I did. It tasted fine, but wasn’t as smooth as I would have liked. In the future, I will mix the pudding powder with the milk first and then blend in the cream cheese. It is also important to make sure that the cream cheese is softened to at least room temperature. Another variation to the recipe that I will try in the future is to make it like a poke cake. This would allow the pudding and pineapple mixture to seep into the cake and have the flavors be better incorporated, rather than just having a cake layer and a toppings layer. Overall, the cake was quite tasty and I was very glad that I’d made it.
The second cake that I made was a Peanut Butter Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting from scratch. I found the recipe on the Life, Love, and Sugar blog and followed the cake recipe to a T. The cake batter itself was so delicious that I literally said “Screw, salmonella!” and licked several spatulas clean. The cakes came out evenly and while they cooled I moved onto the frosting.
I was excited to make a peanut butter buttercream frosting for the first time, and it did not disappoint! The recipe called for 9 cups of confectioner’s sugar, however I only used about 7 cups and I used both additional milk and water to get it to the consistency that I wanted. This lightened the flavor and thickness of the frosting, yet it still packed major peanut butter flavor. Copious amounts of leftover frosting were eaten by myself, my husband, and a few of his friends. I’m still working on my technique when it comes to frosting and decorating. I seem to learn new tips and tricks every time that I hope to implement on my next baking endeavors. I know that cutting off the rounded tops of the cakes will give a more neat and uniform look, but in the past when I’ve attempted this I’ve cut them unevenly, so I didn’t want to risk it this time. Any tips on how to do this well would be greatly appreciated! I loved using the peanut butter chips to decorate and the piping helped to dress up the cake as well. I didn’t end up making the ganache as it was already quite late once I finished the cake, but I would like to try it in the future. My husband loved the cake, which is really all that matters, but I was also happy with how it turned out. It is not as moist, in my opinion, as other cakes that I have made, but the explosion of peanut butter in each bite alongside the creamy frosting definitely makes this a recipe worth repeating!
The full recipe for the Peanut Butter Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting can be found here: Loaded Peanut Butter Layer Cake
The Hawaiian Luau Birthday was a tremendous success, filled with laughter, food, and family. I am beyond thankful that I get to celebrate these special occasions with Carlos for the rest of our lives, and that he has family so close by to share in them with us.
Brianne Elizabeth 